And what of John Thomas View, the name Carey gave to the Virginia State Police? Investigation showed that View's home in Philadelphia had been burglarized on June 19th. Two dollars were missing. Also gone was View's wallet and identification, stolen by a career criminal named Ollie Carey.

Ollie Melvern Carey was born on New Year's Day, 1909 in Portsmouth, Virginia. A cook by trade, Carey was also known as "Buddy Brown," "Chippy," and "Harry Barnes." Carey had been arrested for burglary in the past, and spent six years in prison, from 1941-1947. In the months before Off. Mathews' death Carey had been working with a road construction crew in Rydal. His job afforded him ample opportunity to target homes for break-ins.

In February, 1950 Carey went on trial for the murder of Officer Thomas Mathews. The highly-respected Judge William Dannehower presided over Carey's proceedings in Montgomery County Common Pleas Court. District Attorney J. Stroud Weber led the prosecution team. Attorneys Julian Barnard and James Peck served as defense counsel.

Following closing arguments, the trial jury deliberated for three and a half hours before returning a guilty verdict on February 9th, 1950. Jury foreman Albert Fry of Cheltenham rose and spoke the particulars of the guilty verdict to the court.

"First degree, with the penalty fixed at death."

After several years worth of appeals were exhausted, Carey's sentence was carried out on May 18th, 1953 at Western State Penitentiary in Rockview, Pennsylvania.

Although the death of Officer Mathews took place long ago, he is not forgotten.

The Abington Township Police Department marked the 50th anniversary of his passing with a ceremony on June 29, 1999. Dozens of current and retired officers attended, along with community members and dignitaries. Officer Mathews' widow, Mary, was an honored guest.


 


Officer Tom Mathews was an Army veteran. Here he is seen in his paratrooper uniform with wife Mary.

 

 

 

On May 10th, 2003, a plaque honoring Officer Mathews was unveiled during the dedication of the Police and Fire Memorial. The Memorial is located at the Abington Township complex.

Officer Mathews' name is also a part of the National Law Enforcement Memorial, located in Washington, D.C.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tom Mathews, age 32 at the time of his death, was a decorated veteran of the U.S. Army, where he served in the South Pacific as a paratrooper with the 11th Airborne Division. Before joining the Army he graduated from Northeast Catholic High School in Philadelphia.

Officer Mathews was a popular figure among his police colleagues, and was an active member of Montgomery County's Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 14. Tom served as an official of the F.O.P., as well as a member of its color guard. An excellent marksman, Officer Mathews was officially recognized by the F.O.P. for his pistol skills.

Tom Mathews left behind wife Mary and two-year old son, Michael, as well as numerous friends and colleagues on the Abington Police Department.

It is a truism that the pain and heartache caused by the on-duty death of a police officer never go away. Consider these words, written by Tom Mathews' widow in 1999:

Even though it happened fifty years ago, the pain of sudden loss, while it may occasionally fade into the background, has never escaped my mind for a single day.

Sadly, Mary Mathews McGettigan passed away in June, 2003 at the age of 84. She is buried next to Tom.

Michael Mathews, son of Officer Tom Mathews, relocated to the Dallas, Texas area in 1978. Currently, Michael is employed as a Regional Service Manager for Monitronics. He and wife Donna raised four children, Thomas, Donna Michelle, Michael and Stephen. All four of Officer Mathews' grandchildren are grown, with careers and/or families of their own. Fifty-four years after his father's death, Michael Mathews remains intensely interested in honoring his father's memory.

Tom & Shawna, Trey, Silas, Michal
Donna Michele & Tracy, Stephanie, Kayla, Tracy (not in photo)
Michael & Trisha, Gavin, Grace, Garrett
Stephen & Brandi, Nick (not in photo)

Officer Tom Mathews, a true Abingon hero, is buried at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery in Montgomery County Pennsylvania.

Written by: Lt. Dennis McCauley
Web design by: Liz Webb